For many of the early years, we would get stuck in having the same conversation over and over again without making any real traction or growth. It was extremely difficult to understand why we would get knocked off track and have to start from the beginning again and rehash why we were doing any of this in the first place.
We didn’t understand yet who our church was for.
We did know, however, our community functions as a leaderless organism where everyone has a voice and anyone can ask a question at any point in any moment of our shared time together. When new people would come in, they would understandably have questions — lots of them — and in many cases, strong critiques of what we were doing or not doing.
Our corporate momentum would come to a screeching halt to address these constant questions as best as we could… This was difficult to do at the time because we, as individuals, didn’t know much about the “we” we really were yet. A timidity would always hang and thicken the flow of the room. No one wanted to speak for anyone else so round and round we would go.
Those new people would either join us, or more often than not, get frustrated and leave setting off another wake. More new people would take their place and we would start the cycle over again. Those were tough years. It was an exhausting, dizzying, and often painful process. For those who endured, we learned a valuable lesson.
Why are the people least invested in the life of the community setting the tone for the entire community?
We were allowing people who were mostly just passing through, and certainly not committed to what we were trying to do as a group, to be the loudest voices dictating the terms of our corporate time together. This was creating a miserable experience for everyone — both old and new.
Once, during a particularly intense exchange about whether or not we should establish elders without understanding exactly what would that would entail or mean, a new person with a strong voice started to critique and rebuke our responses to the confusion. Looking back, this unexpected conversation clearly triggered past trauma with spiritually abusive relationships with authority.
The stranger said, “Shame on you all!”
While we were in a new territory of discussing elders, sadly we were not unaccustomed to hearing new people say such things. And we didn’t know how to respond without being rude, so as usual, we would listen to whatever they had to say in whatever way they wanted to say it and cycle would start again. But this time, someone else stood up and said something that hadn’t been said before.
Another new member (but with far more investment in our community) said politely yet with determination, “I will not accept your shame.”
This one act took all the self-righteous power out of the new stranger’s critique. It was the first time we realized we could make healthy adjustments. From that day forward, we had a perspective that allows the terms of the community to be established by those who are most invested. For those least invested or interested in what we are doing, they are still welcome, but it’s not appropriate for them to dominate and dictate our time together. Critiques, questions, and influences from voices further on the fringe were redirected to more interactive conversations outside our shared corporate time.
This marked the day we made a decision about who our church is for…
Church is for those who want to be in the family.
All are still welcome, but we now had much clearer expectations and boundaries between “dating relationships” and the ones that are ready to marry into the family. Church is for those who want to build honest and authentic relationship with one another.
Unfortunately, these kinds of relationships can’t be made from a safe distance. Your whole self needs to be present and available, where the people around you are allowed to move you as much as you are allowed to move them. If this is what you are looking for, we have a seat at the table for you.
We are a group of families striving to live an authentic faith free from artificial social constructs. We do not go to church, rather, we are the church. For 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, we struggle with and how to grow in this reality. We are Liquid.